So here's what I'm working with:
I purchased these awesome "floating" pinewood shelves off of etsy awhile back. I was putting them up in drywall, and since they're pretty heavy and I want to store stuff on them, I got some heavy duty 3/16" toggle bolts to anchor into the drywall for the shelf brackets. Each of these toggle bolts needs a 1/2" pilot hole drilled in, and then the toggle bolt slides in and is set for the screw.
My first two pilot holes are perfect - no issue. On my third, I notice my drill is encountering unexpected resistance. Turns out, my third hole hit a stud in the wall.
So, now I have a gaping 1/2" hole in a stud. I can't use the toggle bolts because they can't flare out properly in the stud wood, and the hole is too big for any stud anchor I can find. A guy at my local hardware store also said that it may be dangerous to try and widen that hole with any anchor since 1/2" has already been bored out of the 2x4 stud.
I've included some pictures of what I am working with in case it helps. [HERE]
Points A & B are my successful toggle bolts, point D is my problem child, and point C is where the final hole would be drilled for the second bracket.
Should I:
- Patch up and fill in point D, then screw into the wall without anchors on points C and D and trust that that will bear the load?
- Use a different type of anchor (maybe a concrete one) that can fill that 1/2" hole?
- Patch it up and make new holes where there isn't any stud?
Or is there some other way I haven't thought of to solve this issue? Thanks in advance!